Fertility and Surrogacy Law FAQs
Experienced fertility attorneys answer reproductive legal processes, surrogacy law, egg donation/sperm donation/embryo donation laws and LGBTQ+ family-building questions we hear most
No — using the same attorney for both intended parents and the gestational carrier creates a direct conflict of interest and is not permitted under most state bar ethics rules for surrogacy agreements. Each party needs their own independent counsel to negotiate and review the contract. This isn’t a formality — it’s what makes the resulting agreement enforceable and is typically required before a clinic, escrow agent, or court will proceed.
Generally, no — most fertility clinics and surrogacy agencies require a gestational carrier to be able to carry a pregnancy safely, and post-menopausal carrying pregnancy is considered high-risk and is rarely approved. Medical screening, not legal status, is usually what disqualifies a candidate here. A reproductive endocrinologist, not an attorney, makes the final medical eligibility call, though your legal agreement will still need to reflect your clinic’s medical clearance requirements.
Yes. In nearly every state, intended parents and their gestational carrier are each required to have independent legal counsel — one attorney cannot ethically represent both sides of a surrogacy agreement, since their interests (compensation, medical decision-making, contingency planning) aren’t identical. Independent representation protects everyone and is typically a requirement for insurance, escrow, and court approval of your parentage order.
There’s no single nationwide legal cap, but most agencies and reproductive endocrinologists limit a gestational carrier to a maximum of 5-6 completed pregnancies (including her own), typically capping surrogacy pregnancies specifically at 4-5, based on ASRM safety guidance rather than statute. Some individual agency contracts set a stricter limit, so always check both your clinic’s medical policy and your agency’s requirements.
Most agencies and clinics require a gestational carrier to be between 21 and 40 years old, though some allow candidates up to 45 with additional medical screening. There is no single nationwide legal minimum age for surrogacy; the age requirement comes primarily from ASRM medical guidelines and individual agency/clinic policy, not state statute — though a handful of states do set their own statutory minimum (usually 21).
Yes. Surrogacy is legal in the majority of U.S. states, but the rules differ significantly from state to state. Some states have detailed surrogacy statutes, some rely on case law, and a small number restrict or discourage compensated surrogacy altogether. Because your rights depend entirely on which state’s law applies to your journey, it’s important to confirm your specific state’s requirements with a fertility attorney before signing any agreement.
Most U.S. agencies cap gestational carrier candidates at around 40-45 years old, based on the increased pregnancy risks associated with advanced maternal age. This is a medical/agency guideline rather than a hard legal ceiling in most states. If you’re above the typical range, some clinics will still consider you with a full medical work-up and additional physician sign-off.
The most common legal risks are: an incomplete or poorly drafted agreement, skipping independent legal review before signing, not obtaining a pre-birth or post-birth parentage order, crossing state lines without confirming both states’ surrogacy laws are compatible, and inadequate escrow protections. Nearly all of these risks are preventable with early legal involvement — before you match with a surrogate or sign any clinic paperwork.
Your gestational surrogacy agreement should include contingency provisions that address exactly this scenario in advance — who makes medical decisions, how additional medical costs are covered, and what happens if the pregnancy involves multiples, bed rest, or other complications. Because these situations are stressful and time-sensitive, the goal of good contract drafting is to remove ambiguity before it’s ever needed, not negotiate it in the moment.
A well-drafted gestational surrogacy agreement should specifically address what happens if the intended parents separate or divorce during the pregnancy, including who retains parental rights and responsibility for the surrogate’s compensation and medical costs. Without this language, a divorce mid-journey can create serious uncertainty for the surrogate and the child’s legal parentage — which is exactly why contingency planning is a core part of contract drafting, not an afterthought.
A pre-birth order (PBO) is a court order, obtained before the baby is born, that legally establishes the intended parents’ parentage so their names go directly on the birth certificate. Not every state allows or requires a PBO — some instead use a post-birth order or a step-parent/second-parent adoption process after delivery. Which route applies to you depends on the state where the birth will take place, so this should be confirmed early in your journey.
“Surrogate” and “gestational carrier” are often used interchangeably, but legally they can mean different things. A gestational carrier has no genetic connection to the child — the embryo is created using the intended parent(s)’ or donors’ egg and sperm. A traditional surrogate uses her own egg, making her the child’s biological mother. Nearly all modern surrogacy arrangements are gestational, which simplifies parentage proceedings considerably.
Gestational surrogacy uses an embryo with no genetic link to the carrier, created via IVF from the intended parents’ and/or donors’ genetic material. Traditional surrogacy uses the surrogate’s own egg, so she is genetically related to the child. Because of the added legal complexity and emotional risk of a genetic connection, traditional surrogacy is rare today, and many attorneys — including our firm — recommend gestational arrangements whenever possible.
A complete gestational surrogacy agreement should address: compensation and reimbursement schedule, medical decision-making authority during pregnancy, contingency plans (multiples, complications, selective reduction), each party’s insurance coverage, escrow account management, parentage order responsibilities, and confidentiality terms. Missing or vague language in any of these areas is one of the most common sources of disputes later in a journey.
Typically, the surrogacy agreement specifies a “choice of law” clause identifying which state’s law governs the contract, and parentage proceedings usually happen in the state where the birth will occur. When intended parents and their gestational carrier live in different states, it’s essential to confirm that both states’ laws are compatible with your plans before you match — some state combinations can create serious complications for your parentage order.
The intended parents are recognized as the legal parents of a child born through surrogacy, but how that recognition happens — a pre-birth order, a post-birth order, or a second-parent adoption — depends on your state and your specific circumstances (marital status, genetic connection, home state law). The gestational carrier, even though she carries the pregnancy, is not the legal parent once a valid surrogacy agreement and court order are in place.
A fertility and surrogacy attorney coordinates and drafts the gestational surrogacy agreement, working alongside (but independently from) the intended parents’ and surrogate’s separate counsel, the fertility clinic, and the escrow agent. Rather than each party assembling their own patchwork of documents, an experienced fertility law firm manages the agreement, the parentage order filing, and the supporting paperwork as one coordinated process from match through birth.
An independent, third-party escrow account holds and disburses funds for the surrogate’s compensation, medical expenses, and journey costs according to the schedule set out in the surrogacy agreement — neither the intended parents nor the surrogate control it directly. This protects both sides: the surrogate is guaranteed payment is set aside and available, and the intended parents get transparent, itemized tracking of every disbursement. Most states don’t legally require escrow, but virtually every reputable agency and attorney insists on it.
Yes — single intended parents, including single men, can legally pursue surrogacy in most U.S. states, though a handful of states restrict or complicate parentage for unmarried intended parents. Because a single parent’s path to a pre-birth or post-birth order can look different from a couple’s, it’s especially important to confirm your specific state’s requirements before matching with a donor and gestational carrier.
In most surrogacy-friendly states, yes — a pre-birth or post-birth parentage order allows both intended fathers to be listed directly on the original birth certificate, without either needing to formally adopt. The exact process (and whether both names go on the certificate automatically or require a follow-up step) depends on the state where the birth occurs, which is why confirming your birth state’s process early avoids delays.
It depends on your state and whether you already obtained a pre-birth or post-birth parentage order recognizing both parents. In states with strong parentage statutes, a court order alone may be sufficient. In others — or when traveling internationally, or when a state’s laws could change — a confirmatory second-parent (or step-parent) adoption adds an extra, harder-to-challenge layer of legal protection for the non-biological parent, which many attorneys recommend even when not strictly required.
For male couples, donor sperm from one or both partners fertilizes a donor egg through IVF, and the resulting embryo(s) are transferred to a gestational carrier. Legally, this means coordinating two separate sets of agreements — the egg/sperm donor agreement(s) and the gestational surrogacy agreement — so that parentage flows cleanly to both intended fathers rather than to the donor or carrier.
The process largely mirrors any newborn passport application — a completed DS-11 form, proof of citizenship (typically the birth certificate listing both legal parents), and both parents’ ID and presence at application. For international surrogacy journeys or travel shortly after birth, having your parentage order and birth certificate already reflect both fathers’ legal status (rather than pending a second-parent adoption) significantly speeds up the passport and any related citizenship documentation.
The first step for same-sex intended parents is usually a consultation with a fertility attorney — before choosing a clinic, agency, or donor — to understand which path (donor insemination, IVF with a gestational carrier, adoption, or a combination) fits your state’s parentage laws and your family goals. From there, the legal and medical tracks run in parallel: your attorney handles donor/surrogacy agreements and parentage orders while your clinic manages the medical process, so nothing is signed or started without your legal protections already in place.
For a male couple, surrogacy typically involves selecting an egg donor and a gestational carrier, creating embryos through IVF using one or both partners’ sperm, and securing legal agreements with the donor and carrier before transfer. A pre-birth or post-birth order then establishes both partners as legal parents. Because two men cannot both be a genetic and gestational match, extra legal coordination between the donor agreement, the surrogacy agreement, and the parentage order is essential to ensure both fathers are recognized.
Most U.S. states with surrogacy statutes apply them equally regardless of the intended parents’ marital status or sexual orientation, but a small number of states have laws or court practices that are less favorable to LGBTQ+ parents, particularly around second-parent recognition. This is one of the biggest reasons LGBTQ+ intended parents should confirm their specific state’s (and, for international journeys, country’s) legal posture before beginning treatment, rather than assuming every state treats parentage the same way.
A typical journey includes: an initial legal consultation, selecting an egg donor and gestational carrier, drafting and signing the donor and surrogacy agreements, IVF and embryo transfer, obtaining a pre-birth order during the pregnancy, the birth itself, and finalizing the birth certificate and (if applicable) a confirmatory adoption. The legal steps run alongside the medical steps rather than after them — starting your attorney relationship early is what keeps the whole timeline on track.
Beyond the standard surrogacy or donor agreements, LGBTQ+ intended parents often need extra attention to: which parent(s) will be listed on the initial birth certificate, whether a second-parent adoption is advisable as a backstop, how parentage will be recognized if you travel or relocate to a less LGBTQ+-friendly state, and — for international parents — how a foreign government will recognize both parents’ rights and citizenship for the child.
Your donor agreement should explicitly terminate the donor’s parental rights and financial obligations, confirm there’s no expectation of contact unless you’ve agreed otherwise, address anonymity and any future medical-history updates, and be reviewed by an attorney experienced with LGBTQ+ family formation specifically — generic or clinic-provided consent forms are not a substitute for an independently negotiated legal agreement.
Look for a fertility clinic, agency, and law firm with a specific, demonstrated track record serving LGBTQ+ intended parents — not just general fertility experience. Fertility & Surrogacy Legal Group has represented same-sex and LGBTQ+ families since 2012 and can also refer you to vetted, LGBTQ+-affirming clinics and agencies as part of your consultation, so your entire team is aligned from day one.
For two-mom families, reciprocal IVF (one partner provides the egg, the other carries the pregnancy) or donor sperm with IUI/IVF are common paths, and typically only a sperm donor agreement is needed. For two-dad families, an egg donor and a gestational carrier are both required, along with agreements for each. The right path depends on your genetic goals, budget, and state’s parentage law — a fertility attorney can help you map the legal implications of each option before you commit.
Nearly all male couples pursuing surrogacy need a gestational carrier (an unrelated, unpaid-in-genetics carrier using a donor egg) rather than a “known surrogate” in the traditional sense, since neither partner can carry the pregnancy. Some couples work with a friend or family member as their gestational carrier (a “known carrier”) instead of an agency match — legally this still requires the same independent counsel, medical screening, and formal agreement as an agency-matched carrier.
Yes, if that’s what both parties agree to — many known-donor arrangements include an ongoing relationship, from occasional updates to regular contact. The key is documenting exactly what’s agreed upon (frequency, type of contact, and boundaries) in the written donor agreement, so expectations are clear on both sides from the start rather than negotiated informally after the child is born.
Generally, no — if the donation went through a licensed physician and a proper legal agreement was in place, the donor has no financial obligation to the child. Without those protections in place, particularly with informal or known-donor arrangements, some courts have found a donor can be treated as a legal parent with support obligations. This is exactly the risk a written donor agreement is designed to eliminate.
Increasingly, no — a growing number of states and countries have passed laws giving donor-conceived children the right to access their donor’s identifying information once they reach adulthood, and most fertility clinics and sperm banks now offer only “open” or “identity-release” donation options rather than true lifetime anonymity. If anonymity is important to you, it’s worth confirming your specific clinic’s and state’s current policy, since this is an area of law that continues to change.
Yes — even when the donor is a friend or family member, a written, attorney-drafted sperm donor agreement is essential. Without one, some states may not automatically terminate a known donor’s parental rights or financial obligations, which can create serious uncertainty for both the donor and the intended parent(s) years later. A proper agreement protects everyone by clearly defining rights, contact expectations, and legal status from the outset.
In most states, a sperm donor who donates through a licensed clinic and signs a proper donor agreement has no parental rights or financial obligations — the intended parent(s) are the legal parents. However, this protection depends on following your state’s specific requirements (often including using a licensed physician for the insemination); donating outside that process, especially informally to someone you know, can leave parentage legally unclear without a separate written agreement.
Going through a licensed sperm bank is an important protective step, but it’s not a complete substitute for your own legal agreement and, where applicable, a parentage order. The sperm bank’s own donor contract protects the bank and the donor — it does not automatically establish your legal parentage. Intended parents should still confirm what additional legal steps their state requires to fully secure their parental rights.
Compensation varies by clinic and region, but sperm donors are typically paid per approved donation rather than a flat fee, with total compensation over a donation series ranging widely. Because compensation terms, tax treatment, and payment structure should be spelled out precisely in the donor agreement — not left to informal understanding — this is one of the specific terms your attorney will help you document clearly.
Generic templates can miss state-specific requirements and rarely address the nuances of your specific situation — known vs. anonymous donation, future contact expectations, medical history updates, or multi-state complications. While a template can be a helpful starting point, having an attorney review or draft the final agreement significantly reduces the risk of an unenforceable or incomplete contract down the line.
Sperm banks and clinics screen for factors including genetic and infectious disease history, certain hereditary conditions, age (typically under 39-40), and a thorough psychological and family medical history review, following FDA and ASRM guidelines. These are medical/screening criteria set by the clinic or bank, not legal disqualifications — though known donors working outside a licensed clinic should still be screened and should have a written agreement regardless.
A complete sperm donor agreement should address: termination of the donor’s parental rights and financial obligations, compensation (if any), anonymity or identity-disclosure terms, whether and how future contact may occur, medical history disclosure and updates, and confidentiality provisions. Leaving any of these open to assumption is one of the most common causes of later disputes between donors and intended parents.
When an egg donation agreement uses a third-party escrow account for compensation — increasingly common, especially for higher-compensation or agency-matched donations — the same independent-escrow protections used in surrogacy apply: funds are held by a neutral third party and released according to the schedule in your agreement, rather than being paid directly between the parties.
Yes — while ASRM guidelines inform most clinics’ medical screening nationally, some states (California among them) have additional statutory protections around egg donor compensation, informed consent, and insurance requirements. If you’re donating or working with a donor in a state with specific egg donor statutes, your agreement should be reviewed against that state’s requirements specifically, not just general clinic practice.
Once a properly executed egg donation agreement is in place and the donor has proceeded through medical screening and retrieval, she generally cannot reclaim parental rights to the resulting eggs or embryos — that’s precisely what the signed agreement is designed to prevent. Before signing and before starting medical treatment, however, a donor retains the right to decline to proceed, which is why thorough legal counseling before the cycle begins matters for both sides.
No — when an egg donation goes through a licensed clinic with a proper legal agreement in place, the donor has no parental rights or obligations to any resulting child. This protection comes from the written donation agreement (not just the clinic’s consent forms), which is why every egg donation should include an attorney-drafted contract clearly terminating the donor’s parental rights before any embryo transfer occurs.
Before starting the process, understand that egg donation involves hormone injections, a minor surgical retrieval procedure, a multi-week time commitment, and — critically — signing a legal agreement that permanently terminates your parental rights to any resulting embryos. Reviewing that agreement with your own independent attorney (not just the clinic’s paperwork) before you begin screening ensures you fully understand what you’re agreeing to.
Egg donor candidates are typically screened out for certain genetic or hereditary conditions, infectious disease markers, significant family psychiatric history, being outside the typical age range (roughly 21-30 for most programs), and failing hormonal or reproductive health screening. These are clinic medical criteria based on ASRM guidance rather than legal restrictions, and specific requirements can vary somewhat by clinic and by state.
Egg donation involves informed consent for a real medical procedure — ovarian stimulation and a retrieval under sedation — and reputable clinics are required to fully disclose the risks and obtain documented consent before proceeding. On the legal side, your donation agreement should separately confirm compensation isn’t contingent on retrieval outcome and that your medical screening results and history remain confidential.
A thorough egg donation agreement should address: compensation and payment schedule, medical screening and the donor’s disclosure obligations, confirmation that the donor has no parental rights to resulting embryos or children, confidentiality and anonymity terms, and what happens to any unused eggs or embryos. As with sperm and embryo agreements, ambiguity in any of these areas is where disputes tend to arise later.
Anonymous donation means the donor and intended parents don’t exchange identifying information, though many clinics now offer only “identity-release” anonymous donation, where the resulting child can request the donor’s identity at adulthood. Known donation means the parties are already acquainted (a friend, family member, or a donor who has agreed to disclosed contact). Both require a full legal agreement — anonymity doesn’t reduce the need for one, and known donation requires additional relationship-boundary terms.
An egg donor’s interests — compensation, medical risk disclosure, confidentiality, and the clear termination of any future parental claim — are not the same as the intended parents’ interests, so one attorney cannot ethically represent both sides. Independent counsel for the donor is standard practice and, like in surrogacy, is typically required by the clinic or agency before the cycle can proceed.
Yes, if both the donating and receiving families agree to it — arrangements range from no contact to occasional updates to an ongoing relationship. As with known sperm and egg donation, the specific terms should be documented clearly in the embryo donation agreement rather than left as an informal understanding between the families.
Yes, if the genetic parents consent and formally document the donation through an embryo donation agreement — legally distinct from an adoption in most states, though it accomplishes a similar goal. The agreement should address the genetic parents’ rights (or termination of rights), any future contact expectations, and the receiving family’s legal parentage of any resulting child.
No — despite sometimes being marketed as “embryo adoption,” embryo donation is legally a contract-based transfer of property/genetic material in most states, not a formal adoption governed by adoption law. This distinction matters: the legal process, required documentation, and parentage protections for the receiving family differ from a traditional adoption, so it’s important to use an embryo donation agreement drafted specifically for that purpose.
Yes — clinic consent forms govern important decisions like embryo disposition, genetic testing, and what happens in the event of death or divorce, but they’re written to protect the clinic, not necessarily to reflect your specific wishes or family situation. Having an attorney review these forms before you sign — ideally before treatment begins, not after — ensures you understand exactly what you’re agreeing to and that your intentions are clearly documented.
What happens depends entirely on the disposition terms in your original consent agreement with the clinic — and, where those terms are silent or contested, on your state’s law and, in some cases, the courts. This is one of the most fought-over areas in fertility law precisely because many couples sign standard clinic consent forms without fully considering divorce as a scenario; addressing it explicitly at the outset avoids a difficult legal battle later.
An embryo disposition agreement is a legal document — usually signed with your fertility clinic before embryos are created or frozen — that specifies what happens to any unused embryos: continued storage, donation to another family, donation to research, or destruction, and who has the authority to make that decision, including what happens in the event of death, divorce, or disagreement between partners.
A complete embryo donation agreement should cover: clear termination of the genetic parents’ rights to any resulting child, whether and how future contact may occur, medical history disclosure obligations, confidentiality, and confirmation of the receiving family’s full legal parentage. As with egg and sperm donation, leaving these terms undocumented is the most common source of later disputes.
Ownership (more precisely, “disposition control”) of frozen embryos belongs to whoever created them and signed the clinic’s consent and disposition agreement — typically the intended parent(s) or the couple who underwent IVF. This is governed by your embryo disposition agreement with the clinic, and, when a donor or surrogate is involved, may also be addressed in your surrogacy or donation agreement. Without clear documentation, embryo ownership disputes can become one of the most legally contentious areas of fertility law.
In order to obtain a Social Security number and card for your child, you’ll submit a request form. It will not be sent automatically. The application for a newborn Social Security number can be found on the website for the United States’ Social Security Administration.
In order to obtain a passport for an infant, you’ll fill out an application. It can be found online or downloaded from the United States Department of State. If you plan to travel out of the country, please inform our staff, as we can help you obtain an expedited passport in a matter of 5-7 days.
First, we go to court and provide the judge with the surrogacy agreement, and a signed statement from your IVF clinic stating that your embryos were transferred to the surrogate. The court then gives us an order that confirms your parentage and protects your records from public scrutiny. We send this court order to the Department of Vital Statistics. The birth certificate is mailed to our offices, and then to you.
Words from Our Families
Meet Our Attorneys
Rich Geisler
Principal & Founder
Erin O. Allen
Senior Associate Attorney
Megan Gruter
Associate Attorney